News & Views

A blog for those interested in what affects, motivates and drives the New York City Nonprofit Sector — written by CRE’s crackerjack consulting team. We hope you use this space to share your thoughts, ask questions and engage in conversations about our city, social justice and the nonprofit sector.

The Broken Machine

By Rashid Littlejohn, Program Assistant/Public Ally - My name is Rashid Littlejohn, a Public Allies Fellow and Program Assistant for Community Resource Exchange (CRE). Public Allies is a nonprofit organization that develops new leaders who are focused on strengthening communities, by partnering us with other nonprofit organizations advocating for social change. I started a nonprofit social justice and environmental leadership group called GCAMP (Genuinely Care About My Planet) in mid-2010 in Brooklyn, NY, which led me to Public Allies. Partnered with CRE for the next ten months, I’ll learn more about the nonprofit sector as Program Assistant and will also blog about some experiences at CRE. This first post, “The Broken Machine,” is a reflection of my first two weeks with CRE.

If you've ever sat in meetings with individuals from the nonprofit sector, one word which is often used is the “system.” What is the system? I speak confidently when I say I am here because I see a problem with the system as apparent as if it were a “machine” operating out of order. I’m in a space of examining what this machine is, how it works, and why it is causing problems.

My first thought was “is the machine the government?” After a discussion with a member of the CRE staff, I began to look into the capitalistic make-up of our country, asking myself “what is wrong with either the government or capitalism that has created such a need for the nonprofit sector?” I then started to visualize a gigantic machine that makes toys. The machine is broken so that every toy made is not working in some way; for each of these issues, repair stores are created to fix the toys. The repair stores represent the nonprofit organizations, the toys are the people who they assist, and the machine could be the government or capitalism. The next question that came to mind is “what is wrong with the machine that it keeps producing dysfunctional toys?” The last thing that came to mind is the rapid pace at which repair stores are opening up, many similar and many different. If you look at it from a “for profit” perspective, it would almost create a sense of competition of who provides the better (or cheaper) repair services.

With all of this bouncing around inside my mind, another member of CRE staff left a report on my desk titled, “Preserving and Developing Nonprofit Capacity in Four New York City Neighborhoods.” This report spoke to the importance of nonprofit collaborations. Keeping my analogy in mind, it means that these repair stores should begin working together to better fix the toys. Now of course this read and the work of CRE put a wide smile on my face, but it was short lived. After attending a Coalition meeting for one of our clients, I realized that so much of what needs to be fixed is uniform in a vast majority of communities that the repair stores serve. I’m now asking “where is the repair store for the broken machine?”

I’ll end by playing devil’s advocate to my own sentiments by saying it’s easy for me to say the government, capitalism, or anything else are the broken machines because it keeps me clear of blame. What if “we” are the broken machine and until we begin collaborating together – government, businesses, nonprofits, and individuals – we’ll never fix ourselves and will continue producing toys that don’t work well?

Find us on:  CRE on Twitter CRE on Facebook  

News and Views


Jean Lobell Fran's Corner nonprofit start-ups board and staff relations Beth Kobliner Advocacy Neighborhood Based Capacity Building Initiative NYCCCOC New York Community Trust nonprofit management HIV/AIDS services providers Karen Erdos Fran Barrett CRE News 30th Anniversary Michael Hickey guest blogger community media Pamela Dicent Nonprofit Huffington Post publications cre computers case statement tips Valyrie Laedlein Maria Mottola handling the unexpected capacity building New York Foundation rockaways Governance as Leadership President Obama board leadership mergers generative fundraising grantmakers NYS Budget Government Updates Holly Delany Cole postponed event jobs Bill Ryan Coaching CRE Executive Search Government News Barbara Blumenthal Louisa Hackett Randall Quan Useful Links New York bookkeeping Development Survey Nonprofit Sustainability executive What is Core? Data nonprofit ownership CRE POV New York City Government Nonprofit Quarterly Peter Block Nonprofit News Philanthropic Collaborative Rona Taylor HR Without HR Interns grantmakers for effective organizations New York Times Ero Gray House Party Client News Barbara Turk nonprofit mergers Featured Items internal controls Ximena Rua-Merkin evaluation leadership Stanford Social Innovation Review Nonprofit Tools staff IT civic engagement Hurricane Sandy Mohan Sikka harvard business school Sector Research Rashid Littlejohn collaborations record keeping executive transition Needs Assessment National and Community Service Jeff Ballow proposal writing I.T. without I.T. Harvard Kennedy School website, resources, announcements Volunteers Data Starved CRE Tips National Committee of Responsive Philanthropy Daring to Lead accountability lower Manhattan Board of Directors strategic alliances Albany queens RFP government Mark Light MAC AIDS Fund nonprofit accountability Funding Updates announcment United Way of NYC hard times foundations Pavitra Menon Alliance for Nonprofit Management nonprofit leaders arts